Do CD-R's work in your P5 CD Player?
 

As you can all see, I'm a newbie here. I have a Silver P5 5-speed. Anyway, I burned a CD of "cruising music", but the CD player won't recognize the CD-R. It will, however, work with regular CD's. Anyone else experience this?

Burned CD's do work in the stock CD player. Did you burn the CD correctly? Put it in a different player, other than the one in your computer, like a diskman or boombox and see if it plays; I doubt it will.

CDR's
 

They worked fine in mine. Did you 'close' the disc? Is it a CDRW or CDR you are trying to use? Not many cd players recognize a CDRW even when closed unless they are made to read MP3 or DVD. I haven't tried it yet to verify but it wont work in any of my other cars.

CDR works in mine. BUT depending on the quality some won't work in my Sony CD Changer. :dunno:

thanks for the replies. Yes, I closed the CD, and it does work in my home theatre system. I'll burn another one... maybe it's a fluke. :)

Mine would play CDRWs too! But it skips like hell :)

And according to this thread, our stock head units are made by different manufactures, so YMMV.

Well, from my experience, if you stick a CD-RW into any player and it plays, it's compatible :) Those non-compatible players won't be able to read the index at all or will say disc error when you load it in.

I would highly disagree. I have the 50 spindles for 8 bucks and they work awesome!!. I have a 12x Iomega burner. They work fine, all my various types of burned cds that are CD-R's, CDRW's dont work. Try to "FInalize the CD", or "Close all Sessions" when burning. You probably didnt burn right? cd quality doesnt matter, it matters for storage when you want the data to last for a long time. Screw quality for cdrws, i have 2 year old so called "cheap" cds that work awesome!

Well, I appreciate the feeback. It must have been a fluke on the last CD, because one I just burned worked fine.

yep CD-R's (both expensive and cheap shit) work in my player as well as CDRW's (only tested memorex 4x CDRW's) they all work flawlessly, haven't tested a store bought cd yet... can't find one

screw quality eh?
maybe you should tell that to my deck...
its very picky
only high-class for this baby
;)
and don't even think i don't know how to burn a disk

rash girl
 

this ol' dog finally learned new tricks!
Made a compilation of drivin' tunes on my home computer... it was a piece of cake!

No skipping or anything! I usually download late at night when the k/s rate is 60+... its a snap! And just in time for Christmas!

My P5 plays CDR's just fine, though there is some tendency to skip when I hit bumps in the road.

Burning CD's is quirky. There are a lot of factors that effect how well a CD is going to work. I've been burning CDs for about 4 years and have used them on a wide variety of players.

This is what I've noted:

-The media doesn't matter to the player as much as it matters to the writer. So to say brand X is better then brand Y on a particular model of reader is misleading at best. The problem is probably with the burner and the media, not the player and the media. I have a Yamaha burner and I use any media with the expception of Memorex. I buy what is cheapest. There is a program that will read the serial number off the disk and tell you what type of media it is and who makes it. How many companies do you think are out there that make the CDs? Not too many. Don't get fooled by marketing, find the cheapest that works with your writer.

-The software can make a difference. I found I had MUCH better luck with Nero Burning Rom than Adaptec/Roxio EZ-CD Creator. I would suggest anyone out there using the Adaptec product stop immediately and buy Nero. I've also used many others and found Nero to be the best.

-Speed. Speed kills. This is what is going to kill most people especially now that the really fast writers (16X,20X) are released. The faster you burn the less time the laser has to make an impression on the record media. This means that the indent is more shallow and harder for the player to pick up. In my opinion this is leading factor for CDR compatibility. There is also a theory that the quality of duplication is better at lower speeds, especially with lower quality writers. If the audio stream contains errors (or peaks and valley's the reader can't under stand because they are not distinct enough) this may materialize as pops, hisses, poorer sounding audio...this may mean less since most people are using MP3's as source which are already of lower quality.

-The brand of CD Writer. Some are better some are worse. Some writers may require that you burn slower others may not have a problem. I use Plextor and Yamaha exlusively. I've used Ricoh, HP and Panasonic as well and found the Plex. and the Yam. to be more reliable.

I write CDs with Nero using Plextor 12X and a Yamaha 8X writer. I typically write AUDIO cds at 4X and buy the cheapest media possible (Gigastorage!). I have zero problems with either burner. It may take a little more time but I am sure that any of my CD's will work in almost any player.

Bottom line. Find what works for you. But when in doubt try writing slower.

Sorry for the rant :)

Jay

rant away
i don't think the big list of rules displayed "no ranting"

so...

if you burn two different brands of cd's on the same burner at the same speed and with the same content, but one cd will work in your deck and the other won't...what would be the logical explanation ?

:dunno: